The Shawshank Redemption is extensively thought of one of many best films ever made, however one compelling concept suggests Andy Dufresne’s innocence — a foundational cornerstone of each the movie and Stephen King’s unique novel — is fictitious. The Shawshank Redemption concept paints Andy Dufresne not as an harmless man making the most effective of a nasty state of affairs, however as a grasp manipulator enjoying a Machiavellian sport with everybody round him. It wonders if Shawshank Redemption hero Andy Dufresne was secretly responsible all alongside and his best deception was pulled on the movie’s narrator, Purple (Morgan Freeman) — with compelling proof this may occasionally even have been the case.
Andy Dufresne got here to Shawshank seeking to the opposite inmates like he was above them, as his quiet, contemplative state was misinterpret as conceitedness. Through the years, whereas changing into a grasp legal on the coronary heart of the Warden’s cash laundering scheme, he grew to become a central determine within the jail group earlier than his escape. Whereas this made for nice storytelling and served to raise the emotional affect of Andy’s escape, it can be seen in a unique mild. As the idea factors out, there’s each likelihood that Andy’s best and most lovable qualities are all an act, and that he is really probably the most conniving and harmful responsible man in Shawshank Penitentiary.
The Andy Dufresne Is Responsible Principle Defined
The compelling Shawshank Redepmtion concept that Andy Dufresne is responsible was first posted on Reddit. The speculation — whose unique poster has sadly since deleted their account — means that the entire Shawshank Redemption plot was in truth the advanced machinations of an ice-cold killer, overlaying his tracks and dealing exhausting to persuade even his buddies of his innocence. The proof, pointing to the parallel between Andy’s love of chess and the intricate necessities of his plan to flee in addition to the important thing level of the movie’s charming however unreliable narrator, is troublesome to shake off as soon as taken in. If accepted as actuality it fully redefines watching Shawshank Redemption — and the idea hinges primarily round Andy’s sport of chess.
The speculation brilliantly alludes to Andy’s actual sport of chess was not being achieved along with his polished rocks, however with the human pawns round him. In accordance with the Shawshank concept Andy is utilizing the guards, inmates, Warden Norton, and notably Purple — his unwavering mouthpiece — as residing chess items. They’re all signifies that Andy makes use of to attain his ends, with Purple’s “knowledge” really being naive. And since, as he admits himself, chess is a “complete f*cking thriller” to Purple, there’s by no means any query from Morgan Freeman’s character of Andy having duplicitous intentions. Purple believes in Andy’s innocence and integrity as a result of that is precisely what grasp manipulator Andy desires.
This went past Andy’s plan to flee Shawshank too, though that is clearly a big motivation for his actions even within the concept. In precise reality, Andy was coolly maneuvering his items for an assault on the Queen (Norton), who he concurrently turns right into a pantomime villain because of relaying his tales to Purple, who by no means really witnesses any of their interactions. And therein lies the genius of the supposed con job: Purple is at all times faraway from the true occasions and may by no means be thought of a dependable narrator. He is spinning a story weaved by Andy, who was able to an immaculate swindle on Norton and all the Shawshank system that Andy himself helped concoct to guard his escape.
How Andy Dufresne Being Responsible Adjustments Shawshank Redemption
Andy Dufresne maintains his harmless all through The Shawshank Redemption. The Andy Dufresne is responsible concept is simply that — a concept — however it’s an fascinating technique to view Shawshank Redemption because it’s surprisingly believable. Whereas the idea fully adjustments the trajectory of the Shawshank Redemption plot, it is not with out benefit, as a result of it matches with what Andy manages to tug off. He had already invented somebody as a part of that fraud scheme for the Warden and over the many years had proved himself to be surprisingly elusive, capable of cover large secrets and techniques and in addition capable of manipulate these round him to guard himself.
Whereas the thought of him utilizing Tommy to guard himself by planting the thought of suppression of the reality and in the end of escape makes Andy much more villain than an anti-hero, it is not exhausting to think about the thought of a protégé groomed for months by a extra spectacular, clever elder. He proved in passing a secret message to Purple about his escape that he knew how suggestion labored. And if Andy was a killer, he can be greater than keen to have somebody die within the identify of making certain his personal story of innocence was strengthened additional (since he will be the one one who advised Purple in regards to the confession Tommy heard). Whereas it’s going to at all times be left to hypothesis, it is fascinating to observe The Shawshank Redemption by way of the lens of Andy Dufresne being responsible.